Evaluation of Factors Related to Long-term Healing in Endodontic Treatment
Orgel, Adam William
Author
Advisor
Date
Embargo until
Language
Book title
Journal
Publisher
Peer Reviewed
Type
Research Area
Jurisdiction
Files
Other Titles
See at
Abstract
Introduction: This study sought to determine the effects of residual root canal bacteria and treatment factors on endodontic treatment outcomes up to 6 years post-operatively using traditional radiography (PA radiographs) and limited cone beam computed tomography (CBCT). Methods: Root canal samples were obtained from 50 patients with pulp necrosis and a periapical lesion, following two-visit treatment using contemporary chemomechanical preparation techniques. PCR, with broad range 16S rDNA bacterial primers, was performed followed by cloning and sequencing on pre-obturation specimens. Periapical and CBCT radiographs were taken at 10 months to 6 years post-treatment. Images were scored by two blinded, calibrated endodontists using the conventional periapical index (PAI) and a CBCT index. Statistical analysis was performed using bivariate and multivariate regression analysis for treatment factors. Kaplan-Meier survival analysis and Pearson's regression analysis was used for year-over-year changes. Results: 41 patients were included in the final data analysis. Recall decreased from 98% at 10-17 months to 51% at 33+ months. The percentage of patients healed at 10-17 months, 18-32 months and 33+ months and overall was 65%, 63%, and 66% respectively. Factors influencing outcomes were presence of bacteria at time of obturation (56% when present, 81% absent), primary versus persistent disease (71% vs. 39%), tooth type (85% anterior,23% molar), obturation to the radiographic apex (100% to the apex, 56% not to the apex), and larger master apical file sizes (73%MAF>45 vs. 36% MAF<45).. Short-term outcomes had a strong positive relationship with final outcome (Pearson's, r2=0.56, p=<0.01). Conclusions: Bacterial DNA presence at the time of obturation adversely affects short-term and intermediate-term endodontic treatment outcomes, but this effect is not found in the long-term. Various patient factors such as tooth type and treatment factors such as master apical file size influence outcomes. Short-term treatment outcomes are good predictors of long-term outcomes.
